2014 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Drafting A Winner

The NHL Draft is the door most of today’s NHL superstars walk through to begin their careers, and since 2005 the Draft has introduced some of the biggest names in the game to fans in every market of the league.

But now, more than perhaps ever before, the importance of using draft picks well shows a direct impact on an organization’s postseason hopes.

2006 Draft

In 2005, Sidney Crosby was the top overall selection and the NHL was hoping to come out of a prolonged lockout with new faces to market to fans. In each of the subsequent drafts, the teams holding the top five overall selections have seen an impact on their NHL roster.

Here are the top five picks in the NHL Draft from 2005-2009, with the current playoff status of both the drafting organization and the player:

team player moved
2005 1 Sidney Crosby PIT yes yes
2 Bobby Ryan ANA yes no traded
3 Jack Johnson CAR no yes traded
4 Benoit Pouliot MIN yes yes traded
5 Carey Price MTL yes yes
2006 1 Erik Johnson STL yes yes traded
2 Jordan Staal PIT yes no traded
3 Jonathan Toews CHI yes yes
4 Nicklas Backstrom WSH no no
5 Phil Kessel BOS yes no traded
2007 1 Patrick Kane CHI yes yes
2 James vanRiemsdyk PHI yes no traded
3 Kyle Turris PHX no no traded
4 Thomas Hickey LAK yes no *waivers
5 Karl Alzner WSH no no
2008 1 Steven Stamkos TB yes yes
2 Drew Doughty LAK yes yes
3 Zach Bogosian ATL no no
4 Alex Pietrangelo STL yes yes
5 Luke Schenn TOR no yes traded
2009 1 John Tavares NYI no no
2 Victor Hedman TB yes yes
3 Matt Duchene COL yes yes
4 Evander Kane ATL no no
5 Brayden Schenn LAK yes yes traded

2007 Draft

As you can see, the top five picks from this window of drafts have made an enormous impact on the NHL. In 2008, two of arguably the five best defensemen in the NHL – Doughty and Pietrangelo – were among the top five selections, while the four forwards included in 2006’s top five overall picks have certainly established themselves as stars in the league.

In 2010, the run of Edmonton picks in the top five began. And the players at the top of the class haven’t made as much of an impact on the postseason -yet.

Tyler Seguin – drafted by Boston, traded to Dallas – has some hardware at home from his days with the Bruins and has led the Stars into the postseason this year. He was the second overall pick in 2010, after Edmonton selected Taylor Hall. Ryan Johansen, selected fourth by Columbus, is the other top-five pick from 2010 to make an appearance in the 2014 playoffs.

Only one player from the top five overall picks in 2011 РGabriel Landeskog Рis still playing this season. Landeskog was selected second overall by Colorado, after Edmonton selected Ryan Nugent-Hopkins.

It’s hard to evaluate a draft class only two seasons after their selection, but two players from the top five picks in 2012 would be playing right now if Montreal’s Alex¬†Galchenyuk was healthy. Columbus’ Ryan Murray played last night in the Blue Jackets loss. Murray and Galchenyuk were the second and third overall picks, respectively, after… you guessed it… Edmonton made the first overall selection (Nail Yakupov).

As you can see, a top five overall pick may be the result of a bad (terrible) previous season, but it can lead to a quick turnaround if the pick is used well. And the 2014 playoffs are loaded with players that didn’t wait long to hear their names called.

7 thoughts on “2014 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Drafting A Winner

  • April 17, 2014 at 9:20 am

    Those pictures are funny – both Toews and Kane look like they’re freshmen who snuck into the senior picture. But they were the two best players from their respective draft classes and the rest is history … and present … and future.

  • April 17, 2014 at 10:27 am

    I can’t understand that table.

  • April 17, 2014 at 10:45 am

    Should be pretty simple, Dave. The top 5 picks listed by year.

    Is the player in the 2014 playoffs?
    Is the drafting organization in the 2014 playoffs?
    Was the player moved by trade or, in the case of Hickey, waivers since they were selected?

  • April 17, 2014 at 10:45 am

    Um I think it is
    Drafting team in playoffs vs drafted player in playoffs vs traded waived still on team

  • April 17, 2014 at 11:20 am

    The Penguins drafted Malkin #2 in 2004. They went through a run where they drafted Malkin, Crosby, and Staal and hit on (receiving a good player) every one of them. That’s incredible…and they could have had Toews in place of Staal.

    As ER said, to hit on the two best players in consecutive drafts is a testament to the Hawks and those players.

  • April 17, 2014 at 1:33 pm

    The Penguins also had the #1 pick in the 2003 draft and the #5 pick in the 2002 draft, so in 5 consecutive draft years they had:

    2002 #5 Ryan Whitney
    2003 #1 Marc-Andre Fluery
    2004 #2 Evgeny Malkin
    2005 #1 Sidney Crosby
    2006 #2 Jordon Staal

  • April 17, 2014 at 2:28 pm

    And yet Edmonton is still in the doldrums.
    2007- #6,15,21

    Piling on the Oilers is a guilty pleasure. Perhaps it stems from the fact Mactavish was drunk and killed somebody by driving. I’m sorry but you cant work for me after that. And to come back as a player after….then coach, and now GM.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *